by Dr. Deah on Dec.17, 2011, under Tasty Morsels: by Dr. Deah Schwartz
Let’s play a game. I say, “East Oakland, California.”
You say, “____________.”
Before I moved here in 1989, I called the local police and checked in about the crime stats. After all, I would most likely be raising a family at some point and wanted to hedge my bets proactively. I was told that the neighborhood was,
“relatively safe with the occasional drive by.”
With that knowledge tucked under my belt, contracts were signed and I moved in. Two weeks later, the Loma Prieta Earthquake hit and my tiny little one story house, nonplussed, re-emerged safe and sound. It was like the airplane scene from The World According to Garp…I have lived here ever since.
The crime in my neighborhood has had its ups and downs over the years with the increases in crime seemingly in sync with economic downturns and desperation. I’ve been robbed once and on another occasion had a SWAT team (no, I’m not exaggerating or using poetic metaphor) in my back yard. But I still “hella love” Oakland. 
One of the gems of this iconoclastic city by The Bay, and especially close to my heart, is Lake Merritt. The Lake is a remarkable place of refuge in the midst of a city known for its turmoil. It is a bird sanctuary, children’s playground, nature and science learning center and the walking, biking and running tracks for many an Oaklander. I joined that “team” of Lake Walkers in 2002 after a serious back injury and have been walking the 3.4 mile circuit almost daily in order to stave off the immobilizing back spasms.
I always walk in the same direction which means that I have, over the years, met about a dozen or so people who are “walking The Lake” at the same time as I but in the opposite direction. It’s amazing that hand waves and one to three word exchanges each day over the course of ten years weaves relationships with people whose names I don’t even know. But it does. When one of my regulars disappeared for a few months, my head was filled with questions about what happened to him…was he okay, had he moved, or merely changed directions? When I saw him one morning back in his regular spot, I waved, “Are you okay? I was worried about you!” He
smiled and we high fived each other. Over the course of the week, as we walked past each other, I learned of his close encounter with a stroke and gradual recovery. Goosebumps ran up and down my spine as I realized that he and I are as much a part of the ecosystem there as the pelicans, cormorants and grebes who have their own special sections of The Lake and come and go with migration patterns as predictable as our daily walks.
But a few weeks ago, things changed. I was the victim of a drive by shouting. No, it wasn’t the first in my lifetime, but it was the first time at The Lake and it cut through me like a scalpel. I was happily walking my route, savoring the sun and grateful for the crisp breeze against my face. As a transplanted New Yawker, I still get a satisfied feeling each December when I can leave my house without a snow shovel and in a tee shirt. I had just passed one of my favorite regulars, a young man in his late twenties perhaps, who sports a pony tail and a black suit. It took about a year before I could elicit a brief two finger forehead salute from him and another year before the wave was accompanied by a smile. Today he actually said, “Hi!” and I was filled with a sense of satisfied connection. Suddenly a car, going in the opposite, direction sped by.
The driver aimed and fired,
“Walk it off Baby, Walk it off!”
And he was gone.
Gone before I could respond. Gone before I could recover. Gone Gone Gone. I was left fuming, stewing, hurting. Now please trust me that I do NOT take violent crime lightly nor do I think that a drive by shooting and a drive by shouting are the same. I know they are
not. But if you would indulge me and work with my metaphor, you’ll understand why this type of “assault” is such a big deal to me. His words eclipsed any and all feelings of pleasure that I had been experiencing. I began to spiral down into a very bad case of the “should haves.” As I trudged along I went through a mental rolodex of: I should have said this, I should have said that. If I had his license plate number I’d find him and tell him this, or that. My imagination on fire, I was in Dr. Deah’s Hollywood.
“Hello officer, I’d like to report a drive by shouting.”
“You mean shooting?”
“Okay, yes…A drive by shooting off of a mouth.”
“Yes there were injuries.”
I even crossed into the territory of blaming the victim.
“Deah, why are you so sensitive? Why can’t you just let these things roll off your shoulders? Why give him so much power?”
I also considered his point of view… perhaps he felt he was helping. Maybe he imagined himself a male Jillian Michaels on wheels and was convinced he was shouting out supportive coach-like positive reinforcement because after all wouldn’t the ONLY reason that I’d be out there power walking around the lake be to walk off my big ol’ booty?
But in the end I kept coming back to the anger. If I saw him again I’d be prepared. I’d head him off at the stop sign. I’d lean in toward the car. I would aim and fire,
“Did I ask for your help??? What you said didn’t help. I don’t want your help! Your help is based on assumptions and a one sided point of view. How dare you intrude into my world only to wound me with your misguided bullets of support. The only thing I had to walk off, Babeee, was the anger, hurt, and humiliation you left in your so called helpful wake.”
Sigh. As if…
As a person who has devoted decades to repairing wounds inflicted by other’s good intentions, it is startling to find that I am still vulnerable when I am the target of an emotional drive by. But I am human and hence, an on-going work in progress. For a few days after the incident I noticed that I was more hyper-vigilant. There was less of a jaunt in my step, and I felt vulnerable. I wondered if everyone assumed that my walking regimen was motivated by my need to fit in to what society expects a woman’s body to look like?
I thought of T-shirts I could wear.
Don’t Help!
OR
Walking 4 my Health NOT 2 B a Size 4
OR
Who Asked U?
OR
Occupy my Big Fat…
Well, you get the idea…
The good news is that my recovery time is quicker than it used to be and I no longer punish myself for not being perfect in the eyes of others. The inner “should have” voices are quiet again and the P.T.S.D. (Post Traumatic Shouting Disorder) symptoms have faded. I’m back at The Lake walking and reveling in all she has to offer.
Yet as I write this I find myself back in Dr. Deah’s Hollywood where this post goes viral and finds its way not just to my fellow “victims” but to the perpetrators. In a cinematic montage we see the people who believe they are doing a good deed, through their unsolicited coaching and commenting, having an epiphany. In a classic light bulbs flashing scene we witness AHA moments, one after one.
We see them in their cars steering clear of The Lake, or if they do drive by, they smile a knowing smile, keep their comments to themselves and do not disrupt The Lake’s placid ecosystem. Change is in the air and all body self-consciousness has evaporated; cormorants fly by and we fade to black.
But until then, here in Dr. Deah’s Oakland, when I walk, I wear my ASDAH T-shirt
and if anyone asks me how I feel about walking around Lake Merritt, my answer will be:
“It’s a great neighborhood, relatively safe, with the occasional drive by.”
If you enjoyed this blog, you can subscribe by clicking here.
And you can purchase our DVD/Workbook by clicking here.
AND HEY…MAKE THIS POST GO VIRAL!!!! CHANGE STARTS HERE!
December 18th, 2011 on 3:14 pm
You’re such an inspirational person! Thank you for sharing this story.
December 18th, 2011 on 3:25 pm
Thank YOU for reading my blog and for your comments!
December 18th, 2011 on 3:43 pm
You can’t help but itch with anger at the wretches who aim their oral bullets without giving you time to answer back. And they always do, because they are cowards. If he had paused for just a second, your walking toward him would have scared him silly for the next year.
Needs a T shirt with the words “Cowards drive by; heroes stop and listen.”
Hugs.
December 18th, 2011 on 3:54 pm
Deah, ah! This is a perfect piece of writing. The rhythmic pace, always so important,your utter success at evading the ever present threat of a sagging middle, the punch at the ends of the paragraphs — this is the kind of work that used to be sought after for incorporation into writing textbooks. In Susan Koppelman’s Hollywood, writing textbook editors all over the English speaking world are reading this mini-essay, this blog post, the column, and realizing how wonderfully it manifests the important writing demands of this genre and deciding that the subject will attract the interest of their target audiences (high school and college students)long enough for the piece to be used to teach the genre requirements. Fade to hundreds of thousands of high school and first year post college education students opening various books to your essay having been told to read the essay for its structural characteristics and noticing what the writer is talking about! They do various takes on the double take. Some smile like they are reading about something familiar to them. Others read as if they are realizing that the intended targets of their drive-by shoutings has a way to shout back, to take license plates, and lodge complaints. They realize that’s a real person being struck by those drive by shoutings. And some people who never leave their homes shudder and think, “I’m really glad I don’t go outside if that’s the kind of thing that happens out there!”
December 18th, 2011 on 4:12 pm
Frannie, that is a wonderful T shirt! Let’s get on cafe press and start cranking them out! Thanks so much for your feedback!
December 18th, 2011 on 4:14 pm
Susan, I like your Hollywood! Even more, I love the favorable critique of the medium and the message.
Thank you.
December 18th, 2011 on 6:34 pm
Thank you.
December 18th, 2011 on 6:59 pm
My honor!
December 19th, 2011 on 9:22 am
I have had three very similar experiences earlier this year as I was cycling. Three times in less than four weeks. You are very generous in ascribing the motive for this behaviour as ‘helping’, I must say I did not think of it like that. Without question it hurt and infuriated in equal measure, but I also had a moment of epiphany. The first time it happened I saw the man (it was always a young man) and Dr. Deah, he was NO oil painting, and I suddenly found myself grinning like an idiot and laughing to myself as I realised how truly bizarre it was that this less than attractive specimen of masculinity should even consider that he had some right to comment on my appearance. For myself that realisation truly has helped me to go on smiling at the insanity of it all.
December 19th, 2011 on 9:32 am
Thanks Demeter! And if it weren’t for finding the humor in life, wow, I couldn’t even imagine how bleak it would all be. As long as we all are taught what is an ideal specimen of beauty, femininity, masculinity, etc. it will always result in someone feeling or being judged as less than, or meets expectations, or exceeds expectations, etc. I remember when I used to fume that Woody Allen, who I never thought was particularly attractive would not only have romantic film relationships with “classic Hollywood beauties” but in his films would be derogatory towards women that he didn’t find particularly attractive. I was like, Who is he to call anyone ugly??? But then I realized, someone out there may think that Mr. Allen was their type and so I was left looking at my own prejudice and preferences. What it came down to for me was that old saying, if one of us is oppressed then we are all oppressed and the work is also about eliminating this “mediautocracy” that dictates who/what is beautiful and with that gives tacit approval for others to judge us.
Again, thanks so much for writing!
December 19th, 2011 on 10:11 am
Beautifully written
December 19th, 2011 on 1:22 pm
Thank you Sue!
December 19th, 2011 on 8:54 pm
Drive by shouters are chicken! What boy would have the guts to shout his judgments if face to face with a grown woman?
I like your statement that if one is oppressed, we all are. Gosh, each human is unique. The ways that we are different from each other are what make us interesting, right?!
What I have felt worried by and worry more and more about is aging. In our ageist society we found lots of motivation in the marketplace to create treatments to disguise aging. But, now, the young people use those very tx to be even more perfect; the result is that the pressure on all of us has risen…
I am a therapist and the last time i sought therapy myself, i looked for the oldest, most experienced therapist I could find. But I don’t see many people thinking this way. It is an advantage in my field, one of the few, to be older and more experienced and yet, I feel pressure to present a youthful persona.
On to Oakland. Oakland, The Mediterranean City! Lake Merritt is unusual and wonderful. Oakland has lots of sections, each with their own character. I had some great times recently at the historical Paramount, one of them with Johnny Mathis. Oakland has an observatory, zoo, creeks, Fenton’s, redwood forest and the list goes on. Oakland is a Golden City.
Signed, Oakland girl
December 20th, 2011 on 10:25 am
Thank you Oakland Girl! And I agree about aging being another area of concern! In fact one of the lines in our show, Leftovers, has Anne mentioning that even if she finally attains the so called perfect body she will then have to deal with aging as another affront to the society of beauty-idolizing that we are living in…and at what point do we just find peace of mind in loving ourselves as we are..wrinkles rolls and all!
Warmly, Dr. Deah