A Unique Resource for Treating Eating Disorders and Body Dissatisfaction

You’re the Top!

by on Nov.30, 2011, under Tasty Morsels: by Dr. Deah Schwartz

Warning: This is a blog rant. It is not a clinically substantiated post; nor is it a touching memoir. Above all, it is NOT a carefully constructed social commentary. It is a rant. That being said, I hope you choose to keep reading.

In a previously written and less “ranty” blog, I wrote about the Narwhal Factor (N.F.). In brief, the Narwhal Factor was my step-mom’s name for the phenomenon of learning a new word or concept e.g. a narwhal, and then seeing or hearing about “narwhals” everywhere for the next few days. Each time it happens I am compelled to ask myself,

“Was it always this prevalent and I just didn’t notice it because I didn’t know about it? Or is it a cosmic re-focusing of The Lens of Knowledge that results in a mystical creationistic event and I am, in fact, manifesting narwhal stories and references everywhere I go?”

***Digression Warning, you can skip this paragraph as it has little to do with what I am writing about: Allow me to point out that the N.F. is different from an Ear Worm, which is when you can’t get a song out of your head Ear Worm Implantation (E.W.I.) usually occurs because the song is a popular tune and you are, in reality, hearing it so frequently that it gets “stuck”.

HP Lovecraft's Cthulhu

Unlike the adorable and intriguing narwhal, I am now experiencing a nightmare version of the Narwhal Factor. It is as if David Lynch and Wes Craven got together to create the worst Narwhal Factor Experience (N.F.E.) in Dr. Deah’s Hollywood, EVER. My latest “narwhal” is The Muffin Top. When did The Muffin Top emerge on the scene as a specific body part? How and why has it become so prevalent in my day to day life? On top of it all, why is the top of the muffin considered so atrocious that everywhere I look someone is telling me that there is something WRONG with my muffin top?   Not just wrong, but abominable! Look, if YOU don’t like the way YOU look or feel with some fat around your hips and want to take a cutesy little label like muffin top and change its name and personae to:  THE Muffin Top, a creature of Cthulhulic proportions go ahead. But why do you feel compelled to make those of us who just may be ok with our hips, hate ourselves?  AAARRGGHH!!  RELEASE THE KRAKEN!!

I told you this would be a rant. If it weren’t I would have methodically researched the history of the term muffin top and collected data to prove or disprove my thesis that its origins are somehow tied to what a real muffin looks like when it comes out of the tin.  I would continue to explore why there is a societal redefinition with negative associations of the term muffin top and suggest that it is based on the Diet Industry’s already well documented modus operandi (M.O.) of selling products to cure an unforgivable social ill. There would be diagrams illustrating the Cyclical Marketing Strategy (C.M.S.) employed by the diet industry and their marketing firms:

Step 1.  Sell muffin top hatred

Step 2.  Sell muffin top removal system

Step 3.  Sell muffin top replacement plan

Step 4.  Repeat step 1.

Step 5. Repeat step 2

Evil Muffin Man

And the green grass grows all around all around … It is infuriating. Honestly, if I didn’t need a computer for my work, I would disconnect from the internet for ever…really! All of a sudden it is the same ad over and over and over, “Kiss your muffin top goodbye,” Get rid of your muffin top in time for the holidays.” And then what happens once the holidays begin…after I have followed your altruistic and sage instructions to banish my muffin top? Am I supposed to continue to follow your advice and eat all of the holiday treats that you are advertising alongside your Muffin Top Removal Products? Why can’t I just keep my muffin top in the first place instead of losing it and gaining it back over and over?  Isn’t that what all of these crash diet ads are really about? Get really thin really fast and then before you know it you will look good enough to eat, um, that is good enough to start eating again!

And speaking of looking “good” from what I can tell, the only time a muffin top really exists is when women, in order to conform to fashion fascism, are wearing pants that are too tight. If you wear a looser waist band, not only are you more comfortable but voila!  No more evil muffin top!!! Hey I just discovered the way to kiss your muffin top goodbye…wear comfortable pants or stay naked! It’s like when we are told that any fat that bulges out from our bra straps is unsightly and needs immediate intervention. Hey I have an idea….don’t wear a bra! Or wear a looser bra…. Or….just tell people to shut up about bra bulge. Is it really destroying their world???

Do men have muffin tops? I don’t think so. They get to have beer bellies. Mmmmm beer, I could use a beer right about now.

Muffin top muffin top tell me when your mother drops, I’ll be there to pick her up…

Oh, that’s mutton chops, never mind. Anyone remember that song?  I haven’t thought about that bratty little sing-song rhyme in a long time. Not surprising that I would now. This whole topic makes me feel bratty and petulant and damn, now I have initiated the mutton chops Ear Worm!!!  If you don’t know what I am talking about go back and read the ***Digression Warning paragraph.

This whole blog is making me want a muffin right now.   A toasted corn, (that’s what they are cawled in New Yawk. You go into a cawfee shop and order a “toasted corn.” You don’t even have to say, “muffin” they know what you mean.

Classic New Yawk "Toasted Corn"

What’s your favorite muffin? I don’t have to ask what your favorite part of the muffin is, I  am guessing that you are one of the 99% that prefer the muffin top!!  And if you don’t…no judgment from me, just invite me to share a muffin with you!

“Kiss your muffin top goodbye,” the ads scream at me! If I could reach my muffin top I would kiss it, lovingly and adoringly because my muffin top is actually fairly new in my world and moved in when my menstrual cycle moved out. Frankly, I’d rather have a full time muffin top as a roommate than my old monthly sub-letter that made me crampy and cranky the third week of every month for 40 years. But alas, even with all of my yoga abilities, kissing my muffin top is a stretch I just can’t figure out. In the meantime I don’t think my boyfriend has any problem kissing my muffin top and I’ll tell you this, you ain’t felt nothing til you’ve had your muffin top kissed and caressed!

I’m thinking it’s time for all of us to reclaim the label Muffin Top and restore it to its natural place as a good thing! It is, after all, the best part of the muffin. It is the part of the muffin that everyone wants to eat first. The part of the muffin that is so good that if you split a muffin with someone and you give them the top it means you really really love them. Perhaps I will even start a website where we can all blog about the virtues of The Muffin Top and wage war against the evil campaign to impugn and malign it.

Look for the inaugural issue of Dr. Deah’s Muffington Post!

Maybe I can recruit Marilyn Wann, author of Fatso? to be a contributor. She just announced the release of her new daily planner that includes a whimsical non-stigmatizing section of  muffin top art. In fact thinking about that section is actually cheering me up quite a bit right now.  Wow, sometimes writing a rant blog can be really motivating; I can’t thank you enough for letting me vent.  Really, you ain’t seen nuthin muffin yet!

 

 

If you enjoyed this blog post, you may want to visit the website Leftoverstogo.com and check out our DVD/Workbook or sign up for our free monthly newsletter!

18 comments for this entry:
  1. Susie Kline

    I started hearing the term years ago. Right around the time hip hugger jeans came back into fashion. Yup, wearing skin tight, low slung jeans means any excess flesh needs somewhere to go!

    I like your ranting! Rant on, my friend!

  2. Frannie Zellman

    Yes, your ranting is fun. And did you know that in some supermarkets, they actually sell muffin tops in containers? Yes..the best part of the muffin all ready to eat. What could be better? :)

    Maybe one day a lot more people will not feel compelled to minimize or belittle their muffin tops.

  3. TBGunther

    Okay, laughing out loud. Love it!

  4. Elizabeth Emanuel

    Hey Deah
    It’s hot here in Australia so my solution to muffin top woes is the SARONG – fits all sizes, does not squeeze body bits into odd food-replica shapes and is cheap and comfortable. I work from home so it is my outfit of choice for the ‘office’. I do wear more conventional clothing when I need to go out, but can’t wait to get back and hang out in my fave wrap.
    Love your blog – keep ranting,
    EE

  5. Randi

    I found those Muffins and in body parts no less.

    Ok thee term Muffin Top began about 10-15 years ago with the reintroduction of low rise jeans. Young girls primarily in their teens started wearing the low rise with short midriff tops (as was the fashion) and those with excess belly flab would not fear or be bothered that their belly bulged over (for lack of better words)their pant line looking as if it was a Muffin Top from the back. The flab would bulge over the pants and the round off toward the bottom of the midriff top or wasitline——Hence resembling a Muffin Top.

    Yet on a positive note, most of these same girls have a decent self concept and esteem for who they are rather than what they look like. They accept their body for what it is, rather then obsessing over a society projected bodily image.

  6. Marla Richter

    I HATE the hip hugger jeans. HATE them. Watch all women even the so called thin ones have skin falling over the top. AND, watch, the damn things are falling off. All my grand kids are consistantly pulling up their pants. Me too. I dont have enough hands to carry a purse, keys, phone and one for pulling up my pants. I have had them fall off in my house while cooking. Did I say I HATE them. I hope pants come to the Real waist once again. I saw that LL Bean has them. I ordered a pair.

  7. vesta44

    Oh man, I loved the hip-hugger jeans and I never had a muffin top from wearing them, but that could have been because those hip-hugging jeans hit me at my waist…..LOL!!!!!!!! Too bad they don’t make them in my size anymore, I’d be wearing them again, especially if they made them with bell-bottoms (yeah, yeah, I know, I’m dating myself, bell-bottoms were the in thing when I was a teenager back in the late 60s, early 70s). It’s funny, those bell-bottom pants are a flattering look for fat women, for some reason (at least, they are for this fat woman, I made a pair a few years ago and wore them out, got more compliments on them, need to find that pattern……). But muffin tops? Nothing wrong with muffin tops, not on muffins or on people.

  8. Stef Maruch

    All the attempts to get me to hate the muffintop look are lost on me because I think muffintops are really, really cute.

    I have my narwhal ready to take on anyone who disagrees with me.

  9. Dr. Deah

    And your Narwhal’s name is Stabby! :D

  10. Amy

    I am just loving your rant, rant away, Dr. Deah especially since it seems you felt better at the end of it. There was a Seinfeld episode where Elaine tried a business selling only muffin tops, clearly the best part of the muffin.
    I also hate when equating something we love so much such as muffin tops with a part of the body we are supposed to dislike,the muffin top, makes no sense to me. As always, leaves us scratching our heads, saying, huh??? I hate it when there is a barrage of what we should get rid of, why and who are you to tell us this…?? It seems that I have joined your rant. I feel better….Thanks Dr. Deah!!!

  11. Bill Fabrey

    Speaking personally, and not representing anyone else or any organization, and for what little it may be worth, I humbly submit that I ADMIRE muffin tops. Both kinds.

    Re: Narwhal effect – I experience that every couple of days, every time I learn some new word or expression. Seems like everyone else already knew about it!

  12. kate217

    Everyone knows the top is the best part of the muffin!

  13. Dr. Deah

    indeed! Thanks for writing Kate!

  14. Dr. Deah

    Thanks for your comment Bill!!! And yes, the Narwhal effect is prolific! Thanks so much for your comment!

  15. Dr. Deah

    I am so thrilled that my writing inspired your writing which resulted in your feeling better! “My work is done here!” :) thanks so much for writing!

  16. Marla Richter

    Isnt anyone uncomfortable in them? I have an apple shaped body. So I am thinner at my hips, that is why they fall off. I dont care how good or bad they look. I do not like how they feel when wearing them. I have seen woman with “muffin tops” that actually looked like a big beer belly hanging over the low waste. If that is fine with her then so be it. That is just uncomfortable. Like I said earlier, they are always falling down and I spend hours pulling them up. I just wish they made both styles, waist and hip. I dont have a choice. Thanks for the rant too!

  17. Heather

    Muffin top makes me feel like having a muffin. I haven’t had one for years. It didn’t stop me from gaining weight though…I keep going up as usual. But I stopped eating wheat for allergy reasons this year again. This article takes me back to the time I used to skip breakfast, and everyone at work had a wonderful large bran muffin with a huge top at coffee break. They were double size. They were delicious. And because I was kind of anorexic at the time, maybe because of very bad nerves, I could not always finish my huge muffin, but definitely, the top was always the best part. As for hip huggers, I was alive back in the time they were in style before, and never liked them. I tried some one a few years ago, and I hated the feeling so much, I couldn’t stand them, and now, I always wear deep waisted pants at all times when wearing pants. Also, I can’t stand any more stiff hard fabrics, and usually love my soft, sweat pants of various types; or leggings with skirts. I agree that I always looked better without clothes, as most clothes were never made to fit my A shaped figure. Of course, only in private. But muffin tops I never have; only soccer balls.

Leave a Reply