A Unique Resource for Treating Eating Disorders and Body Dissatisfaction

NO STRINGS ATTACHED

by on Sep.10, 2011, under Tasty Morsels: by Dr. Deah Schwartz

The expression no strings attached has its origin in the fabric industry.  If a piece of cloth was imperfect, a string would be placed there to let people know that there was a flaw.  A perfect piece of material, therefore, had no strings attached.

The expression no strings attached is also associated with traps and deception.  Elmer Fudd would place a big juicy carrot under a box with a string, Bugs would grab the carrot, a string would be pulled, the carrot would disappear and the box would twap the wabbit. A truly free gift of a carrot, therefore, has no strings attached.

People struggling with eating disorders and body dissatisfaction frequently find themselves tangled up in the strings of their loved ones’, families’, and friends’ support.   It’s a delicate subject to address because:

  • Their intentions come from a place of love.
  • Their concern is authentic.
  • The source of their actions is from the heart.

But a bribe is not support.

When someone says, “When you reach your goal weight I will buy you a new wardrobe,” that’s a bribe.

Or, “When you reach your goal weight I’ll give you five dollars for every pound you lost (or gained), that’s a bribe.

Conversely, if someone were to say, “I know you are strapped for money and if you need help buying clothes, please let me know,” that’s support.

Or, “I know money is tight right now and you want to join a gym, so if you need help paying for that just let me know,” that’s support.

There is a huge difference between the two.  One is truly caring and supportive with no strings attached. The other is a bribe, completely based on the premise, “If you do this for me, then I’ll do this for you.”

Now I know, people will insist they are not saying that you need to change your weight or your eating habits for them.  More likely they insist, “I am only thinking of you and want to help and support you.”

And in my opinion, most people REALLY believe this is true down to their core.  In most cases, our families and friends ARE concerned about our health and happiness.  Unfortunately they are also convinced that optimal health and happiness are attached to a certain number on the scale. But what happens if I accept the support aka bribe?  Does that mean that if I reach my goal weight, you buy me new clothes and I gain the weight back again, that I am unworthy of the support you offered in the first place?  Have I used up all of my “help cards?”

So what if we remove the words, “When you reach your goal weight,” and replace them with, “How can I support you in your decision to adopt healthier and happier lifestyle habits?”  Ahhh, big difference!  Then you are entering into a supportive relationship with your loved one that is NOT outcome based, but process based, on-going, infinite. And isn’t that what loved ones, family, and friends are really there for?

I am not saying this is easy.  This fine line between support and bribery, as I mentioned before, is a delicate subject.  Extrinsic positive reinforcement can be a powerful motivator.  And most of us are used to different kinds of reward systems for attaining goals.  But when the goal is an ongoing lifestyle change that is not attached to a specific weight or waist size, I’d like to suggest that any support offered or taken have…

NO STRINGS ATTACHED; like a perfect piece of fabric.

 

 

4 comments for this entry:
  1. Amy

    This piece resonnated with me so much. When I was about 12 and was already in the throes of puberty, I had gained weight that year to the point where I was uncomfortable with my body for the first time. I was coming to terms with what it looked like, what it felt like and deciding what I should do about all of these new feelings. My father sat me down and told me if I lost, I think it was 10 pounds, he would give me $100 for a new wardrobe. I still remember the sting of that conversation. There was no support, it was strictly a bribe which embarrassed me to no end. All I could think was, why wasn’t he giving me money to buy clothes because I deserved them, should I not have new clothes because I gotten fat? I only deserved them if I compled to his desire for me to be thinner. I took the bribe, I have to admit. I never felt supported and was not complimented when I did lose the weight, that was the moment that I became self-conscious about my body. That feeling stayed with me throughout my life especially around men. It is only now in my 50′s that I have gained self acceptance around my body issues.

  2. Susan Koppelman

    I like this. I like learning where the term “no strings attached” comes from. I like the distinction you make between support and bribe. I never did stop biting my nails so I never got to collect the bribe offered for doing so — a fancy manicure set. But that’s okay — the woman who offered it to me is long dead.

  3. Dayna Harpster

    I’ve never believed in bribes passed off as motivators, including for getting good grades. It seems to me nothing less than a power play on the part of the giver … of course that notion can be rejected if the taker decides to take for his or her own reasons. The person who gives dollars for A’s or pounds lost is exerting control over the other person’s life, almost co-opting the other person’s accomplishment, if it happens. This post is good at clarifying how to be helpful without controlling another person.

  4. Dr. Deah

    Thank you Dayna! I’m glad the post struck a positive chord with you!

Leave a Reply