by Dr. Deah on Apr.24, 2011, under Tasty Morsels: by Dr. Deah Schwartz
One of these days the world will be so different that when I wake up in the morning I will be able to go the entire day without finding material for Tasty Morsels, Leftovers To Go’s blog about body dissatisfaction, eating disorders, size discrimination, and fat acceptance. For a while, as I wean from my “ha-blog-tual” routine, I see myself gleefully writing about these concerns in the past tense. I will have some nostalgic posts on how the paradigm shift finally happened, and the occasional recognition of some of the amazing people that worked diligently to effect the cultural change from oppressive societal governing of our bodies to a world of tolerance and individual choice.
But alas, that day is not here yet and every day blog material collects on my psyche like lint in a lint trap. Case in point:
Recently, I was on an airplane, winging my way to present with the Fat Studies Cohort at the Joint Conference of Popular and American Culture Associations. I would be one of a scintillating and diverse group of fat activist researchers, professors, artists, and students presenting on the topics of fat/size discrimination and how fat people are perceived, represented and treated vis a vis the global popular culture media. I was nervous, excited, and filled with anticipation of what I would see, experience, learn, and how my presentation would be received by those who attended. But before that happened, this happened:
I rarely talk about myself in terms of my weight or size because I fiercely believe we are not just numbers on a scale or a BMI measurement. I have been so many weights throughout my life and hence learned who I am on the inside stayed constant despite my weight. How I was treated by others… THAT was the changing variable. It is important that I mention for the purpose of this post that currently I am too fat to be labeled thin in this society and too thin to be labeled fat by some in the fat movement. Add to this the fact that no matter what I weigh some genetic fluke results in my having a pointy face, I can, when sitting down, “pass” as a thinner person.
I can function as a double agent, a secret spy, an undercover operative. 
This isn’t the only time in my life that I have functioned in this capacity. When I was a student at the University of New Hampshire, I was one of perhaps ten Jewish students on the campus. Because of my red hair, green eyes, and occasional pint of Guinness Stout in my hand (drinking age back then was 18 so we college girls could drink legally) everyone understandably assumed I was an Irish gal. Because of this for the first time in my 18 years I heard first hand snide Anti-Semitic comments. A nudge nudge wink wink in my direction coupled with a comment like, “You know how those Jews are,” or, “All Jews look the same.” I was stunned and speechless at first. (Me speechless??? That is rare.) After a while I was able to shock people by playing along just enough before unveiling the fact that I was Jewish; thus pointing out how narrow minded and misinformed they were. Still, it was painful to realize that my parent’s stories of Anti-Semites were not just the scars from a bygone era or generation of Holocaust survivors. There were kids my age spewing the same crap on a college campus. I became an activist and an educator.
So there I was on the airplane. Snuggled under the no longer complimentary blanket that I bought last year and bring with me on every flight. Walking down the aisle was a woman with luscious dark curly hair, a bright red t-shirt that happily boasted of a white water rafting achievement, and a standard size roller bag to put in the overhead compartment. 
She stopped at the row in front of mine and began struggling to put her bag in the bin. She was about five feet tall and was having difficulty managing the task. No one offered to help her. I could not help her because I was in the window seat boxed in by two other passengers. The person next to me rolled his eyes and commented to me, “It figures she’d have such a large bag, her clothes must be gigantic!”
I began to respond just as she finally managed to get her suitcase situated, take her seat, when another woman came down the aisle. She had luscious dark curly hair, sported a blue t-shirt from Michigan and had a
standard size roller bag. She was about five feet tall and as she struggled with her bag three people jumped up to help her.
By the time the “tumult” subsided the person sitting next to me was plugged into his ear buds and the moment to reveal my secret identity and challenge his prejudice had passed. Needless to say I was left with an all too familiar feeling of anger, sadness, fatigue, and resolve to keep trying to make changes to these attitudes and assumptions. I mean honestly, the ONLY visible difference between the two women struggling with their bags was their weight and the fatter woman received negative comments and no help while the thinner woman was pampered and catered to because somehow she was more deserving of the help.
When we were deplaning, the man sitting next to me took his standard size roller bag out of the overhead bin. I raised my eyebrows and started to say, “Looks like you have the same size bag that she has, what is your excuse for its size?” But he quickly traipsed down the aisle leaving me wanting to scream, “Figures you’d have such a large bag your egotistical, judgmental attitude must take up a lot of space!” 
But this one got away leaving me fortunately and unfortunately with material for yet another blog.
And I headed out to San Antonio hungrily anticipating being with and learning from like-minded people who would help anyone struggling with a suitcase no matter how much they weighed. 
April 26th, 2011 on 6:24 am
Dr. Schwartz,
I encounter this sort of thing all the time. Here is something I wrote a while ago;
I wrote this to process my thoughts and wanted to share it. PLEASE DO NOT COMMENT BACK TO ME ON THIS. Everyone in certainly entitled to their own opinion, but what I wrote below is NOT the beginning of a conversation.
While at work today I finally find out the name of a singer that I had heard and knew by seeing her but did not know her name. It was Adele. She is English and has a mournful voice that I really like. So while on my break I looked her up on youtube.com to listen to some of her songs before I went back to work. I found a few and all of them had been viewed several thousand times. I sat there digging the ballad and saw that one of the videos had 5,799 comments. I scroll down to see that virtually every single comment was about her weight, or responding to someone else’s post about her weight. I finally cried.
I am not angry, I’m hurt and sad. Weight is still an accepted form of prejudice. I am deeply aware of weight issues and while I know “some guys are into it”, I also know that this prejudice isn’t about men’s weight; it’s about women that are overweight. The thought that society is okay with a double standard is not new, but I have moved past anger or shock or saying “oh these people need something better to do than to simply comment on how a woman looks” The fact is these words and thoughts are held be a large chunk of American Society, it’s not a minority.
Every day I am finding more and more blogs by overweight women about being okay with being fat. But what I am more disturbed about in the hate from other people. The look people give to fat woman is like they have something gross in their mouth. They simply can’t believe that a woman will “allow” herself to be so obese. “Why can’t that woman just stop eating? How can she “let” herself get so fat?” But right now I am not going into food addiction or compulsive eating, what I am writing about is the prejudice and the hate. The vibe is so negative that it punches my chest like a fist. I know this is real, I know that people do feel, think and act this way to others and it’s hurting me.
April 27th, 2011 on 11:09 am
As I read Dr. Deah’s blog and the heart felt commentary above, I think about the many times I have lost 20 lbs or more and people will always say, “You look great!” My only thoughts in this moment is always, “What did I look like before”, it is always a back door compliment, always said with a judgement attached, the “looking great” compliment never comes to anyone with extra pounds on their bodies. Why is that? Why can’t we look great no matter how big or small our bodies are, I just do not understand how those thoughts are formulated. I do not know how compliments became tag lines for everything, “You’d be beautiful if…” I know Dr. Deah has commented on this many times, this is what angers me, hurts me, that these compliments only come from those people when what they are seeing coincides what society has deemed as being normal and how did that happen? We have to keep asking the questions and questioning those who point the fingers.